Pshenitsyn M.Yu. Multi-Criteria Selection of Digital Infrastructure Architecture in Public-Private Partnership Projects: Reconciling Stakeholder Priorities

Maksim Yu. Pshenitsyn 
Volgograd State University, Volgograd, Russian Federation

Abstract. The study substantiates a multi-criteria analysis toolkit for selecting digital infrastructure architecture in public-private partnership projects while reconciling divergent stakeholder priorities. Such decisions rest on conflicting criteria in incomparable units: total cost of ownership, flexibility, information security, and risk. Intuitive choices therefore remain opaque and resist audit under shared responsibility. The research combines three methods. The analytic hierarchy process derives criteria weights fr om pairwise comparisons of stakeholder judgements and verifies their consistency; the technique for order of preference by similarity to ideal solution (TOPSIS) ranks alternatives by relative closeness. Multi attribute utility theory captures stakeholder risk aversion. A conditional example comparing on-premises, cloud, and hybrid architectures yields weights of 0.32 for information security, 0.28 for cost of ownership, 0.22 for flexibility, and 0.18 for risk. The consistency ratio is 0.06, below the acceptance threshold. Closeness coefficients reach 0.719 for the hybrid architecture, 0.527 for the cloud, and 0.301 for on-premises. Sensitivity analysis confirms the hybrid lead across security weights from 0.22 to 0.45; the cloud architecture prevails only below a critical weight near 0.2. Wh ere parties disagree, individual priorities rather than judgements should be aggregated: divergence reflects legitimate interests, not expert error. A fuzzy extension of the ranking method covers qualitative criteria. Criteria weights and the switching point thus become observable quantities rather than the outcome of implicit bargaining. 

Key words: multi-criteria analysis, ranking stability analysis, digital infrastructure architecture, cloud and hybrid solutions, public-private partnership, stakeholders. 

Citation. Pshenitsyn M.Yu., 2026. Multi-Criteria Selection of Digital Infrastructure Architecture in Public-Private Partnership Projects: Reconciling Stakeholder Priorities. Regionalnaya ekonomika. Yug Rossii [Regional Economy. South of Russia], vol. 14, no. 3, pp. 122-128. (in Russian). DOI: https://doi.org/10.15688/re.volsu.2026.3.11

Attachments: /upload/medialibrary/78a/2ns3oq3q6e1ool9tobtm5ayuz2i3qrh3.pdf